Logos Bible Software Blog

« National Bible Week Essay Contest | Main | Syntax Searching and Epistolary Form Criticism: Greeting Form »

November 22, 2006

Syntax Searching and Epistolary Form Criticism: Disclosure Form

Read the first post in this series...

An example of the disclosure form is found in 1Th 4.13:

Description of Form

Smith provides a concise summary of the structure of the disclosure form as identified by Mullins:

Mullins has isolated the disclosure form, as a distinct literary form which is used in the NT. He examined the form in terms of structure first. By doing so he observes that this form has four constituent elements: verb of wishing, infinitive of a noetic verb, person addressed and information disclosed. Next he examined the form in terms of content and observed that the verb of wishing is typically ????, the infinitive of a noetic verb used is typically ????????? (the tense varies) or ???????, the person addressed is either second person singular or plural and the content of the information disclosed is diverse and usually found within a ??? clause.[1]

White discusses the form briefly in his article:

This form may be delineated in terms of its three principal elements: (i) the verb of disclosure, often a two-membered unit consisting of a verb of desiring (???? or ????????) in the first person indicative, and the verb of knowing (???????) in the infinitive form; (ii) the vocative of address (???????, “brothers,” in the five examples from Paul); and (iii) the subject to be disclosed introduced by ???.[2]

The common points of these descriptions include:

• verb of wishing/desiring
• verb of knowing, in the infinitive mood
• a ??? or ??? clause further explicating the subject to be disclosed.

Smith reports Mullins determines the following references as containing instances of the disclosure formula: Ro 1.13; 11.25; 1Co 10.1; 11.3; 12.1; 2Co 1.8; Col 2.1; 1Th 4.13.[3]

Because the third item (??? or ??? clause) is variable as Mullins’ reported instances demonstrate, candidate instances of the disclosure formula can be located simply taking the first two items into account.

The Form in OpenText.org SAGNT

Locating the disclosure form in the OpenText.org SAGNT involves searching for clauses that contain a Predicator with ???? and that also contain an embedded clause (infinives are typically encoded as embedded clauses) with lexical forms of either ?????? or ????.[4] Below is the query that will find Smith and Mullins’ reported instances.[5]

Search results in Logos Bible Software are presented in both Greek and English, with respective structures highlighted in each language. In this particular search, the silver background represents the content of the clause; the orange represents each clause component. Bibliography

Mullins, T. Y., “Disclosure: a Literary Form in the New Testament”, NovT 7 (1964), pp. 44-50.
White, J.L., “Introductory Formulae in the Body of the Pauline Letter”, JBL 90 (1971), pp. 91-97.
Smith, C.A., Timothy’s Task, Paul’s Prospect: A New Reading of 2 Timothy (Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press, 2006). pp. 10,

Endnotes

[1] Smith, 10.

[2] White, 93.

[3] Smith, 11.

[4] Andrew Pitts, in a forthcoming review of Logos Bible Software 3.0 to be published in the Journal of Greco-Roman Judaism and Christianity, uses a similar search with similar results as an example of the capability of the OpenText.org SAGNT.

[5] As of November, 2006, this is not strictly true. 1Co 12.1 is erroneously tagged in the current version of the OpenText.org SAGNT. This error has been flagged for correction and should be updated in a future release of the database.

Comments

Posted by: Mike Hogue at November 23, 2006 8:27 AM

Posted by: Larry Logue at November 23, 2007 10:37 AM

Post a comment

Name:

Email Address:

URL:
Remember Me? YesNo

Comments: (you may use HTML tags for style)